To the Editor:
Columnist Torrey Snow’s pro/con synopsis of the data center controversy checks the usual boxes: the centers’ massive drain on electricity and water resources, community opposition, etc, contrasted with the supposed benefits of revenues they generate. But he completely misses the most dangerous aspect of the build-out: It all based on huge amounts of highly volatile debt!
Ominously, the data center leaseholder firm Coreweave, the hyperscaler Oracle and the lender Softbank are all suddenly borrowing at 10%-and-higher interest—junk-bond levels! Meta, Amazon and others have long made “circular” debt deals whereby they lend $100-billion-multiples of borrowed money to each other to purchase cybernetics capacities, advanced semiconductor chips, or promises of electric power from Peter to Paul and back. Meanwhile, Oracle, for example, has lost half its stock value in five months!
Atop this rickety foundation sits the biggest infrastructure investment in history. Constant-dollar A.I./ data center outlays now approximately equal the 20th Century highway program and the 19th Century rail expansion combined. The likes of Nvidia, Microsoft, Meta, etc, have spent 7-8% of GDP solely on information infrastructure in the past two years, whereas the entire nation has previously never allocated more than 3% of GDP for all infrastructural purposes, public and private, combined!
This frenzy makes the wild leveraging of sub-prime mortgages that factored so heavily in the 2008 crash, seem like the most prudent financial practice in comparison! The greater risk still is that the popping of the A.I. bubble will detonate the much larger mass of financial derivatives whose nominal values exceed the real physical-economic base by orders of magnitude.
Mr. Snow’s piece unfortunately exemplifies the conceptual blunder that helped create this mess. Equating monetary streams with “value” means that gambling, pornography, maybe even narcotics trafficking, are now the stable pillars of a healthy, growing economy. Nobody can deny the potential real gains in productivity associated with A.I. But data mining for the modern-day version of the Tulip Bubble, crypto-currency, is pure speculative waste.
Genuine value is about sustaining growing populations at ever-improving living standards. Absent sweeping economic reorganization, more “debtor centers” won’t accomplish that.
Sincerely, Doug Mallouk