On Nov. 13, the national parliament of Germany passed legislation giving the domestic and foreign intelligence agencies new powers to act more aggressively against “enemies” of the state and society, particularly in preemptive actions such as secretly entering homes and taking action against explosives or weapons. The Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution (Bundesamt für Verfassungsschutz, BfV) is now authorized to disrupt infrastructure through cyberattacks, reroute data traffic, delete information stored for use in planned attacks, or even deliberately spread disinformation. The BfV is furthermore enabled to restrict its cooperation with individual state offices in the future and withhold information categorized as “sensitive” for the security of Germany. A good part of this “categorization” will come from the foreign intelligence agency, BND; for instance, in the form of labeling persons and institutions as “pro-Russian” or “controlled by Russia.”

The empowerment of the BfV is generally seen as a measure to deny information to the state agency of Saxony-Anhalt, which is going to have a new government led by the rightwing Alternative for Germany (AfD) party, which not only is labeled by the present German government to be rightwing-extremist but also to be an alleged channel for Russia for gathering sensitive information about Germany or for carrying out acts of sabotage.

Presented as a “reform of the century” by Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt, the legislation did not receive an overwhelming majority at the parliamentary vote, with 308 votes in favor, 190 votes against, and 71 abstentions; there is opposition and broad disagreement. But the new legislation is leaving doors wide open to earmark individuals, institutions, companies, and publications for sudden law enforcement action, as well as confiscation and destruction of data and other property.

Critics of the legislation have warned against a rebirth of the infamous Gestapo of the Nazi past and the Stasi of East Germany, because the empowerment of the BfV and BND is unprecedented in the history of the entire post-WW II Federal Republic of Germany. It would be easy to fabricate alleged emergencies to justify the lifting of civil and constitutional rights—a taste of that already given during the pre-legislation period by poorly documented alleged “Russian hands” behind various drone incidents, cyber attacks, and fake-information campaigns.

Because of this, suits against the legislation can be expected at the Constitutional Court, citing it as a violation of constitutional and civil rights instead of being a defense of democracy. In Germany in particular, but also outside of it, the role of Carl Schmitt, the leading 1930s propagandist of “emergencies” that were used to justify the Nazi elimination of political adversaries and march to total power, will be remembered. There were good reasons for legislators in 80 years of post-war Germany to insist on the strict separation between police powers and the limitation of BfV and BND as information-gathering agencies. It can only be hoped that the Constitutional Court is aware of that tradition and will rule against the legislation.