Iranian Foreign Ministry spokesman Ismaeil Baghaei reported Thursday morning that he turned down an interview request from The New York Times. Baqaei said that by presenting baseless claims regarding Iran’s dams, the newspaper has effectively placed itself at the service of promoting the narrative of aggressors. These aggressors, during their illegal war against Iran, demonstrated a complete disregard for international humanitarian law, and the most basic ethical principles, reported IRNA.

”The New York Times has dramatically failed to uphold the fundamental principles of professional journalism,” he said, referring to the article published on Nov. 16, entitled “War May Answer Longtime Riddle of Iranian Dams Built for No Clear Reason.” “By advancing unsubstantiated allegations that serve the narrative of aggressors who have already demonstrated utter disregard for international humanitarian law (IHL) and basic moral principles in their unlawful war against my homeland, it is effectively participating in the aggressors’ psychological warfare and media operations, (and) seeking to shape public opinion in order to legitimize the aggression.”

The backlash against the article has been tremendous, with numerous comments on X accusing the Times authors of setting up the justification for future attacks on Iran’s civilian infrastructure. Nicole Taylor, a spokesperson for the Times, responded that the Times report accurately cited seven experts on Iran’s environment and military presence. “Our journalists provided readers with a deeper understanding of Iranian infrastructure investment and the effects of U.S. and Israeli attacks on civilians,” Taylor claimed. “Framing the independent reporting as a pretext for violence is dangerous.”

Even some of the experts cited by the Times rejected its logic. “Speculation is not evidence, and spatial proximity is not causality,” Kaveh Madani, an environmental scientist and Research Professor at the City University of New York’s Remote Sensing Earth Systems, wrote in Forbes. “Iran’s major dams, water transfer tunnels, and many military installations are concentrated in mountainous regions. Geography, geology, topography, water availability, and engineering constraints influence where such facilities can be built,” he writes. “Finding both in similar geographical settings is therefore not necessarily surprising.” Connecting the dots the way the Times story does is not rigorous journalism, he argued.

Dr. Nima Shokri, who is quoted extensively in the Times report, said, in a [https://x.com/NimaShokri_GHI/status/2122440135979749674] statement on X, that “the proximity of dams to military targets does not establish why those dams were built, nor does it justify attacks on them.” He otherwise defended its reporting on his statements and said that it “does not advocate attacks on dams or water infrastructure,” to which most of the comments in reply were negative, accusing Shokri of trying to cover himself for allowing his work to be used in such a nefarious way.